Boyle started his college career at Jackson State CC, where he threw 45 innings en route to Region VII Runner-Up honors. He transferred to Division I Virginia Commonwealth University, where he did not appear in any games during the 2020 season. He spent the summer of 2020 with the Bismarck Bull Moose of the Northwoods League, appearing in 10 games as he posted a 1.29 ERA with 15 strikeouts. In 2021, Boyle transferred to Toledo and made three appearances for a total of two innings on the mound. Boyle returned to Bismarck for the summer of 2021, pitching in 21 games while posting a 5.32 ERA as he struck out 21 batters. For Boyle’s final year of college, he transferred to Division II Drury University, where he played in 17 games and held a 6.32 ERA. Boyle returned to Bismarck for a third straight summer in 2022, where he played just eight games while maintaining a 2.25 ERA before being picked up by the Missoula PaddleHeads where he spent the remainder of the summer. For the PaddleHeads in 2022, Boyle posted a 4.54 ERA in 18 appearances while striking out 29 batters. Boyle returned to Missoula for the 2023 season, as he made five appearances while delivering a 3.00 ERA.